Living alone versus living with roommates is a debate that defines the experience of being young in a city. Living alone offers privacy, freedom, silence, and the ability to design your space exactly as you want it. There is nobody eating your food, nobody having loud phone calls at midnight, and nobody whose cleaning standards conflict with yours. Living with roommates offers companionship, significantly lower costs, shared responsibilities, and the kind of spontaneous social life that solo living cannot provide. The answer depends heavily on personality, finances, and life stage. But when thousands of people who have experienced both are forced to choose — which wins?